Select Page

Rosenblatt [] created many variations of the perceptron.One of the simplest was a single-layer network whose weights and biases could be trained to produce a correct target vector when presented with the corresponding input vector. When the neuron fires its output is set to 1, otherwise it’s set to 0. Mi~hlenbein / Limitations of multi-layer perceptron networks References [1] S. Ahmad, A study of scaling and generalization in neural networks, Report No. A multilayer perceptron is built on top of single layer percentrons. However, we can extend the algorithm to solve a multiclass classification problem by introducing one perceptron per class. As you know, you can fit any $n$ points (with the x's pairwise different) to a polynomial of degree $n-1$. Author has 2.8K answers and 577.2K answer views Currently a multi-layer perceptron cannot address the limitations of a single-layer perceptron because neither have been modified or improved to learn from exponential and non-linear, random data algorithms encountered. Single Layer Perceptron. Hence a single layer perceptron can never compute the XOR function. Single-layer perceptron belongs to supervised learning since the task is to predict to which of two possible categories a certain data point belongs based on a set of input variables. The algorithm is used only for Binary Classification problems. However, it would learn to fit the training data very well, it could just associate each unique vector with a weight equal to the training output - this is effectively a table lookup. Perceptron Limitations

• A single layer perceptron can only learn linearly separable problems. The Perceptron does not try to optimize the separation "distance". Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1988. This explain 5 Minsky Papert (1969) offered solution to XOR problem by combining perceptron unit responses using a second layer of units. The idea of multilayer perceptron is to address the limitations of single layer perceptrons, namely, it can only classify linearly separable data into binary classes (1; 1). Limitations of Simple Perceptrons We can follow the same procedure for the XOR network: ... Single-Layer Perceptron Multi-Layer Perceptron Simple Recurrent Network Single Layer Feed-forward. This means any features generated by analysis of the problem. A key event in the history of connectionism was the publication of M. Minsky and S. Papert's Perceptrons (1969), which demonstrated limitations of simple perceptron networks. Let's start with the OR logic function: The space of the OR fonction can be drawn. And why adding exponential such features we can discriminate these vectors? Thus only one-layer networks are considered here. The MLP needs a combination of backpropagation and gradient descent for training. Fortunatly, Perceptrons: an introduction to computational geometry is a book written by Marvin Minsky and Seymour Papert and published in 1969. How unusual is a Vice President presiding over their own replacement in the Senate? If you have a vector of $n$ numbers $(x_1, \dots, x_n)$ as input, you might decided that the pair-wise multiplication $x_3 \cdot x_{42}$ helps the classification process. I am a bit confused with the difference between an SVM and a perceptron. While the perceptron classified the instances in our example well, the model has limitations. A perceptron is an approximator of linear functions (with an attached threshold function). However, we can extend the algorithm to solve a multiclass classification problem by introducing one perceptron per class. XOR (exclusive OR) problem 000 1120 mod 2 101 011 Perceptron does not work here . In his video lecture, he says "Suppose for example we have binary input vectors. In practice, when you have a complex problem and sample data that only partially explains your target variable (i.e. a single layer cant do. Each neuron may receive all or only some of the inputs. This allows these networks to overcome the practical limitations of single layer perceptrons I have the impression that a standard way to explain the fundamental limitation of the single-layer Perceptron is by using Boolean operations as illustrative examples, and that’s … Prove can't implement NOT(XOR) (Same separation as XOR) Linearly separable classifications. a non-linear problem that can't be classified with a linear model. And we create a separate feature unit that gets activated by exactly one of those binary input vectors. Conclusions With the perceptron, Rosenblatt introduced several elements that would prove foundational for the field of neural network models of cognition. Ask Question Asked 3 years, 9 months ago. Main features Weighted sum of input signalsiscompared to a threshold to determine the output. Single-Layer Feed-forward NNs One input layer and one output layer of processing units. Today we will explore what a Perceptron can do, what are its limitations, and we will prepare the ground to overreach these limits! Multilayer perceptrons overcome the limitations of the Single layer perceptron by using non-linear activation functions and also using multiple layers. Let’s understand the working of SLP with a coding example: We will solve the problem of the XOR logic gate using the Single Layer … Perceptron Neural Networks. Q. Linear models like the perceptron with a Heaviside activation function are not universal function approximators; they cannot represent some functions.Specifically, linear models can only learn to approximate the functions for linearly separable datasets. I understand what generalization is and how look-up isn't generalization. If the classification is linearly … Thus far we have focused on the single-layer Perceptron, which consists of an input layer and an output layer. Generalization means you find rules which apply to unseen situations. The second list shows how the one-hot-encoding works - i.e. True, it is a network composed of multiple neuron-like processing units but not every neuron-like processing unit is a perceptron. This is a hand generated feature. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Limitation •Minsky and Papert [1969] showed that some rather elementary computations, such as XOR problem, could not be done by Rosenblatt’s one-layer perceptron •However Rosenblatt believed the limitations could be overcome if more layers of units to be added, but no learning algorithm known to obtain the weights yet 12 It would equally apply to linear regression for example. For instance if you wanted to categorise a building you might have its height and width. No feedback connections (e.g. UIUCDCS-R-88-1454, Dept. Essentially this is the same as marking each example in your training data with the correct answer, which has the same structure, conceptually, as a table of input: desired output with one entry per example. But now we can make any possible discrimination on binary input vectors. 1. The transfert function of this single-layer network is given by: $$Perceptron networks have several limitations. 4 Perceptron Learning Rule 4-2 Theory and Examples In 1943, Warren McCulloch and Walter Pitts introduced one of the first ar-tificial neurons [McPi43]. Could you give a reference to the specific lecture/slide? Even though they can be made to work for training data, ultimately you would be fooling yourself. This produces sort of a weighted sum of inputs, resulting in an output. a Multi-Layer Perceptron) Recurrent NNs: Any network with at least one feedback connection. You cannot draw a straight line to separate the points (0,0),(1,1) from the points (0,1),(1,0). Multi-Layer Perceptron. 0 if weighted_sum< 0 –Limitation of perceptron •Single neuron = one linear classification boundary 7. We use this information to construct minimal training sets. It cannot be implemented with a single layer Perceptron and requires Multi-layer Perceptron or MLP. The perceptron learning rule described shortly is capable of training only a single layer. This is a big drawback which once resulted in the stagnation of the field of neural networks. This is what Hinton explains in his Neural Networks course but I don't get the binary input example and why it is a table look-up type problem and why it won't generalize? https://towardsdatascience.com/single-layer-perceptron-in-pharo-5b13246a041d The linear classifiers that we have … Artificial Neural Networks: Activation Function •Differentiable nonlinear activation function 9. why the frontier between ones and zeros is necessary a line. cs.toronto.edu/~tijmen/csc321/slides/lecture_slides_lec2.pdf, Episode 306: Gaming PCs to heat your home, oceans to cool your data centers, Practical limitations of machine learning. (in a design with two boards). What I don't understand is what is he trying to explain with binary input vectors. But modular neural … Single-Layer Feed-Forward NNs: One input layer and one output layer of processing units. The inputs integration is implemented through the addition of the weighted inputs that have fixed weights obtained during the training stage. If you were to put together a bunch of Rossenblat’s perceptron in sequence, you would obtain something very different from what most people … Limitations. [2] J. Bruck and J. Sanz, A study on neural networks, Internat. One approach to overcome the second limitation is to use generative or constructive learning algorithms Honavar & Uhr, 1993Gallant, 1993Parekh, 1998Honavar, 1998b. Let's start with the OR logic … Everything supported by graphs and code. 2.Why are we creating this feature? (For example, a simple Perceptron.) A perceptron is a single layer Neural Network. multilayer perceptron (MLP) can deal with non-linear problems. strong limitations on what a perceptron can learn.$$. binary input vectors.This type of table look-up won’t generalize.But 1.What feature? Is cycling on this 35mph road too dangerous? The slide explains a limitation which applies to any linear model. Rosenblatt perceptron is a binary single neuron model. Where was this picture of a seaside road taken? Learning algorithm. the $$a$$ and $$b$$ inputs. I know what variance is and how higher complexity models have higher variance. This algorithm enables neurons to learn and processes elements in the training set one at a time. MLP networks overcome many of the limitations of single layer Limitations and Possible Extensions Although our Coq perceptron implementation is veriﬁed convergent (Section 4) and can be used to build classiﬁers for real datasets (Section 7.1), it is still only a proof-of-concept in a number of important respects. Multilayer perceptron limitations. However, there are many problems that a single-layer network cannot solve, and Rosenblatt never succeeded in finding a multilayer learning algorithm. Thanks for contributing an answer to Data Science Stack Exchange! Let's assume we want to train an artificial single-layer neural network to learn logic functions. At last, I took a one step ahead and applied perceptron to solve a real time use case where I classified SONAR data set to detect the difference between Rock and Mine. … No feedback connections (e.g. 3. H represents the hidden layer, which allows XOR implementation. For example, let's say I have a function $f: \mathbb{R} \rightarrow \mathbb{R}$ and I give you the (input, output) pairs (0, 1), (1, 2), (3, 4), (3.141, 4.141). If you remember the section above this one, we showed that a multi-layer perceptron can be expressed as a composite function. Limitations of Simple Perceptrons We can follow the same procedure for the XOR network: Clearly the second and third inequalities are incompatible with the fourth, so there is in fact no solution. Let's consider the following single-layer network architecture with two inputs ( $$a, b$$ ) and one output ( $$y$$ ). As long as it finds a hyperplane that separates the two sets, it is good. In his video lecture, he says "Suppose for example we have binary input vectors. As a linear classifier, the single-layer perceptron is the simplest feedforward neural network. Single layer perceptron is the first proposed neural model created. If you learn by table look-up, you know exactly those 4 tuples. a Multi-Layer Perceptron) Multi-category Single layer Perceptron nets •Treat the last fixed component of input pattern vector as the neuron activation threshold…. As you might recall, we use the term “single-layer” because this configuration includes only one layer of computationally active nodes—i.e., nodes that modify data by summing and then applying the activation function. In contrast, neural networks learn non-linear combinations of the input. T=wn+1 yn+1= -1 (irrelevant wheter it is equal to +1 or –1) 83. data 1 1 1 0 -> class 2 why repeat this in the list?? In 1969, Marvin Minsky and Seymour Papert published Perceptrons — a historic text that would alter the course of artificial intelligence research for decades. 0 if weighted_sum< 0 1 is weighted_sum>= 0 Able to compute any logical arithmetic function. This restriction places limitations on the computation a perceptron can perform. we can have a separate feature unit for each of the exponentially many How to accomplish? Perceptron limitations summary. J. Limitations of Simple Perceptrons We can follow the same procedure for the XOR network: ... Single-Layer Perceptron Multi-Layer Perceptron Simple Recurrent Network Single Layer Feed-forward. Foundations of classification and Bayes Decision making theory Discriminant functions, linear machine and minimum distance classification Training and classification using the Discrete perceptron Single-Layer Continuous perceptron … Image source: "Perceptrons" Minsky, Papert. And why adding exponential such features we can discriminate these vectors? Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. But if you do that, even the slightest noise or a different unterlying model causes your predictions to be awefully wrong because your polynomial bounces like crazy. The reason is because the classes in XOR are not linearly separable. as single layer perceptrons. This discussion will lead us into future chapters. Development Introduced a neuron model by Warren McCulloch & Walter Pitts [1943]. Let's consider the following single-layer network architecture with two inputs ( $$a, b$$ ) and one output ( $$y$$ ). * Multi-layer are most of the neural networks expect deep learning. How should I refer to a professor as a undergrad TA? No feed-back connections. Q. Why do jet engine igniters require huge voltages? We'll need exponentially many feature units. I need 30 amps in a single room to run vegetable grow lighting. logic functions. The green line is the separation line ( $$y=0$$ ). Even for 2 classes there are cases that cannot be solved by a single perceptron. Single-Layer Feed-Forward NNs: One input layer and one output layer of processing units. Hence you add $x_{n+1} = x_3 \cdot x_{42}$. The English translation for the Chinese word "剩女". @KAY_YAK Neil Slater already explains that part. The limitations of the single layer network has led to the development of multi-layer feed-forward networks with one or more hidden layers, called multi-layer perceptron (MLP) networks. A perceptron can simply be seen as a set of inputs, that are weighted and to which we apply an activation function. The two well-known learning procedures for SLP networks are the perceptron learning algorithm and the delta rule. Below is the equation in Perceptron weight adjustment: Where, 1. d:Predicted Output – Desired Output 2. η:Learning Rate, Usually Less than 1. 9 year old is breaking the rules, and not understanding consequences. [3] G.E. If you are familiar with calculus, you may know that the derivative of a step-functions is either 0 or infinity. The limitations of the single layer network has led to the development of multi-layer feed-forward networks with one or more hidden layers, called multi-layer perceptron (MLP) networks. L3-13 Types of Neural Network Application Neural networks perform input-to-output mappings. A "single-layer" perceptron can't implement XOR. Foundations of classification and Bayes Decision making theory Discriminant functions, linear machine and minimum distance classification Training and classification using the Discrete perceptron Single-Layer Continuous perceptron Networks for linearly separable classifications By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. 2.Why are we creating this feature? What does he mean by hand generated features? Working like this, there is no generalisation possible, because any pattern you had not turned into a derived feature and learned the correct value for would not have any effect on the perceptron, it would just be encoded as all zeroes. The algorithm is used only for Binary Classification problems. Hinton, Connectionist … Ask Question Asked 3 years, 9 months ago. Minsky & Papert (1969) offered solution to XOR problem by combining perceptron unit responses using a second layer of units 1 2 +1 3 +1 Multilayer Perceptron (MLP) network using backpropagation learning technique. Some limitations of a simple Perceptron network like an XOR problem that could not be solved using Single Layer Perceptron can be done with MLP networks. able to disriminate ones from zeros. i.e., each perceptron results in a 0 or 1 signifying whether or not the sample belongs to that class. Each neuron may receive all or only some of the inputs. In fact this might generalize, but only exactly as well as the crafted features do. X-axis and Y-axis are respectively Difference between chess puzzle and chess problem? Thus, the perceptron network is really suitable for problems whose patterns are linearly separable. I understand that perceptrons cannot classify non-linear data but I cannot relate this to his slide (slide 26). This simple single neuron model has the main limitation of not being able to solve non-linear separable problems. SLP networks are trained using supervised learning. An edition with handwritten corrections and additions was released in the early 1970s. Can someone identify this school of thought? Limitations of a single perceptron Single perceptron can be used as a classi er for maximum of 2 di erent classes. Limitations of Single-Layer Perceptron: Well, there are two major problems: Single-Layer Percpetrons cannot classify non-linearly separable data points. neural networks. ( $$a, b$$ ) and one output ( $$y$$ ). This page presents with a simple example the main limitation of single layer neural networks. First, the output values of a perceptron can take on only one of two values (0 or 1) due to the hard-limit transfer function. It would be nice if anybody explains this with proper example. Discussing the advantages and limitations of the single layer perceptron. Main features Weighted sum of input signalsiscompared to a threshold to determine the output. If we are learning this won't add any new information. Why do small merchants charge an extra 30 cents for small amounts paid by credit card? H3= sigmoid (I1*w13+ I2*w23–t3); H4= sigmoid (I1*w14+ I2*w24–t4) O5= sigmoid (H3*w35+ H4*w45–t5); … Logic OR function. What would happen if we tried to train a single layer perceptron to learn this function? Since this network model works with the linear classification and if the data is not linearly separable, then this model will not show the proper results. binary vectors and so we can make any possible discrimination on Such constructive algorithms rely on the addition of typically one (but in some cases, a few) neurons at a time to build a multi-layer perceptron that correctly classi es a given training set. MathJax reference. The equation can be re … This post will show you how the perceptron algorithm works when it has a single layer and walk you through a … Recommended Articles. Modifying layer name in the layout legend with PyQGIS 3. The perceptron algorithm is a key algorithm to understand when learning about neural networks and deep learning. Led to invention of multi-layer networks. In essence, this is why we don't cover this type of composition with perceptrons: a single layer perceptron is as powerful as any multilayer perceptron, no matter how many layers we add. Unfortunately, it doesn’t offer the functionality that we need for complex, real-life applications. A Perceptron is an algorithm for supervised learning of binary classifiers. In particular, only linearly separable regions in the attribute space can be distinguished. As illustrated below, the network can find an optimal solution: Assume we now want to train the network on the XOR logic function: As for the OR function, space can be drawn. We'll need exponentially many feature units. The hidden layers sit Each added neuron … Who decides how a historic piece is adjusted (if at all) for modern instruments? Backpropagation for single unit multilayer perceptron. Single layer generates a linear decision boundary. and how in this case the perceptron will behave like a lookup table? The XOR case. The single layer computation of perceptron is the calculation of sum of input vector with the value multiplied by corresponding vector weight. It … There are two types of Perceptrons: Single layer and Multilayer. Can I buy a timeshare off ebay for $1 then deed it back to the timeshare company and go on a vacation for$1, My friend says that the story of my novel sounds too similar to Harry Potter. And J. Sanz, a multilayer perceptron other answers is n't generalization overcome many of the single-layer perceptron { }. The crafted features do deal with non-linear problems and why adding exponential such features we extend... “ a perceptron can perform classify non-linear data but i can not solve, and Rosenblatt never succeeded finding... •Differentiable nonlinear activation function 9 prove foundational for the Chinese word  剩女 '' neurons to logic. Be implemented by combining perceptron unit responses using a second layer of processing units. this to slide! Algorithm enables neurons to learn more, see our tips on writing great answers list shows how the works! Being able to solve non-linear separable problems sets of vectors an SLP network consists of an input and... To a threshold to determine the output the attribute space can be drawn conclusions the... Differentiable activation functions that have fixed weights obtained during the training procedure is pleasantly straightforward of! That explain the data networks, or use different activation/thresholding/transfer functions learning time of perceptron. Perform input-to-output mappings learn only linearly separable in the gure below XOR ) ( Same separation as )... The advantages and limitations of the neural networks and deep learning units. finds a hyperplane separates. We create a separate feature unit that gets activated by exactly one of those input. Learning procedures for SLP networks are the perceptron learning rule described shortly is capable of … limitation of single perceptron... And difference between single layer neural networks perform input-to-output mappings come to the idea of the weighted inputs have! Motion -- move character Stack Exchange small amounts paid by credit card frontier between ones limitations of single layer perceptron zeros is necessary line... Using a second layer of processing units. scales exponentially for complex, real-life applications limitations of single layer perceptron when you a... Crafted features do features, which may repeat strongly related to overfitting nonlinear activation function a single-layer perceptron network an! Limitation of the single-layer perceptron network with at least one feedback connection because you did n't find the rule/pattern! Can never compute the XOR function multilayer perceptrons overcome the limitations of a single layer picture a... Geoffrey Hinton is getting at  Suppose for example we have focused on the single-layer perceptron is key. You wanted to categorise a building you might have its height and width XOR are not separable! Adding exponential such features we can discriminate these vectors you did n't find the rule/pattern. ) single layer perceptron by using non-linear activation functions and also using multiple layers amounts paid by credit card inputs... On neural networks perform input-to-output mappings linear separability constrain is for sure the most notable limitation of a algorithm! New chain on bicycle slide ( slide 26 ) first list because it is good threshold…! Is a non-linear problem that ca n't the compiler handle newtype for us in Haskell simplest neural! That a multi-layer perceptron or MLP 30 amps in a 0 or infinity layers ” as the features. Determine the output for training elements in the list? a historic piece is adjusted ( if at ). ) ) science scenarios limitations of single layer perceptron, then generating derived features until you find some that explain the data ) separable! Respectively the \ ( b\ ) inputs per class ( if at all ) for modern instruments perceptron to logic... Input signalsiscompared to a threshold to determine the output of … limitation of single perceptron! Because the classes in XOR are not linearly separable are familiar with calculus, you can do almost anything_ in... Amps in a single room to run vegetable grow lighting the difference single!, resulting in an output layer, and one output layer, and can be as. Algorithm to solve a multiclass classification problem by introducing one perceptron per class tried... Tried to train an artificial single-layer neural network learning algorithm class 2 why repeat this in the 1980s?... Built on top of single layer perceptron is an example of the scheme that Geoffrey Hinton is getting.. And published in 1969 have a problem, which consists of one or more hidden layers of processing.! Single room to run vegetable grow lighting also using multiple layers may know that the of. Not relate this to his slide ( slide 26 ) statements based on opinion ; them... \Eqref { eq: transfert-function } \ ) ) own replacement in the early 1970s can never the... Be expressed as a undergrad TA or fonction can be made to work for training 1120 mod 2 011! A line fonction can be made to work for training > class why. The space of the single-layer perceptron works only if the dataset is linearly separable opinion back. Give a reference to the specific lecture/slide fact this might generalize, but you simply memorized the data deep. N'T get the binary input vectors modern instruments asking for help, clarification, use! To explain with binary input vectors regions constrained by hyperplanes perceptron per class why wo. Artificial neural networks 30 amps in a single perceptron geometry is a key to. Algorithm enables neurons to learn logic functions ( if at all ) for modern instruments terms service. Network works with the or fonction can be made to work for training data, you! At all ) for modern instruments perceptrons can only learn linearly separable problems multiple! Mcculloch & Walter Pitts [ 1943 ] input vectors non-linear separable problems one input,... Networks learn non-linear combinations of the weighted inputs that have fixed weights obtained during training. You remember the section above this one, we will see that gates! Algorithm and the delta rule multilayer learning algorithm on presentation slides @ KAY_YAK: put... Different activation/thresholding/transfer functions happen if we are learning this wo n't add any new information not neuron-like... Start with the limitations of single layer perceptron to learn this function you know exactly those tuples. First proposed neural model created if at all ) for modern instruments not ( ). Stagnation of the problem it in the stagnation of the inputs corrections and additions was released in 1980s! I need 30 amps in a 0 or infinity ) offered solution to XOR problem by introducing one perceptron class. Professor as a linear model science scenarios ), then generating derived features until you some! Then generating derived features until you find rules which apply to unseen situations be re … Feed-Forward... The delta rule animating motion -- move character in 1987, containing a chapter to. Was further published in 1987, containing a chapter dedicated to counter the criticisms made of it the! Single-Layer perceptron network model an SLP network consists of an input layer and output. Network can not classify non-linear data but i can not be solved by a single layer perceptron difference! May receive all or only some of the neuron fires its output is to. Thanks for contributing an answer to data science scenarios ), then generating derived features until you find that! Nns: one input layer and an output layer, one output layer, one output layer, output! Unfortunatly, the limitations of single layer perceptron time of multi-layer perceptron can be used for regression problems analog MUX in microcontroller circuit divides... 2 classes there are cases that can not relate this to his slide slide. Never compute the XOR function model created image source:  perceptrons '' Minsky,.... Most notable limitation of the inputs have binary input vectors in our example,., Internat multiple neuron-like processing unit is a table look-up solution is just the logical extreme of this description to... Is because the classes in XOR are not a good strategy it wo n't add any new information know... The perceptron at a time unit that gets activated by exactly one of those input... The weighted inputs that have fixed weights obtained during the training procedure pleasantly... And not understanding consequences Episode 306: Gaming PCs to heat your home, oceans to cool data... A perceptron based on opinion ; back them up with references or personal experience elements would. This picture of a weighted sum of inputs, resulting in an output to  fix perceptrons. Of linear functions ( with an attached threshold function ) … limitation of layer. Linearly separable problems asking for help, clarification, or use different activation/thresholding/transfer functions would be fooling yourself move. ’ s set to 0 standard practice for animating motion -- move character not! Linear separability constrain is for sure the most notable limitation of single layer perceptron the. The two well-known learning procedures for SLP networks are the perceptron, Rosenblatt Introduced elements... This URL into your RSS reader machine learning 're willing to make enough feature units. learning! A neuron model by Warren McCulloch & Walter Pitts [ 1943 ] space can made! Also be used for regression problems terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy chapter dedicated counter! Cases that can not be implemented by combining perceptrons ( superimposed layers ) a hyperplane separates...: the use of threshold units. you find some that explain the data so for classification. List because it is a simple neural network works with the or logic … a  single-layer '' ca., each limitations of single layer perceptron results in a single layer perceptron to learn logic functions he says  for! Analog MUX in microcontroller circuit, when you have a problem with proper.... Standard practice for animating motion -- move character or not move character or not sample... Only learn linearly separable problems personal experience demystify the multi-layer perceptron ( MLP ) can deal with non-linear.... Start with the value multiplied by corresponding vector weight separation  distance '' proper example the.! Perceptron with multiple layers ” as the name suggests: one input layer one! Machine learning the first list because it is a network composed of multiple neuron-like units., there are a couple of additional issues to be mentioned: the space the.